Local Search for Lawyers: How Online Visibility Leads to Clients

Written by Andrew McDermott in Blog, Legal, Running Your Business
March 30, 2018:

Lawyers near me feature image


You have a big problem.

Your clients can’t tell you and your competitors apart. If you’re reading this, you’re probably an experienced attorney. You know the law. You’re aware of how things really work inside this complicated legal system of ours.

Your clients on the other hand, don’t.

Their expectations tend to be simple, naive and occasionally unrealistic. What’s worse, they know it. They know they don’t understand what you do.

Which means they’re lost without you.

What kind of lawyer are you anyway?

You’ll have to choose.  

Your clients are flying blind. When it comes to choosing an attorney most clients aren’t particularly sophisticated. They don’t know where to begin, what to look for or the questions they should ask. When it comes to evaluating an attorney, your clients don’t know what they don’t know.

Here’s why their blindness is your problem.

When it comes to local search, the vast majority of lawyers make two very common mistakes.

  1. They expect their clients to find them.
  2. They expect their clients to evaluate them accurately.

1. They expect their clients to find them.

Most clients use local search in some shape or fashion to find the attorneys they work with. They use Google. They rely on referrals and  recommendations. They troll review sites like Avvo. They ask for help on social media. If usual methods don’t work (and they’re desperate), they scrape a list together and they start making calls.

If you’re visible and you (or your agency) push the right buttons, you get their attention. If these prospects have a positive experience with you, you get more attention.

Here’s why that’s a problem.

Most lawyers aren’t visible. They’re not getting a lot of traffic to their sites. They don’t present their law firm to clients at the right time and place, with the right message. So, they don’t win clients.

Simple, right?

And if clients are able to find them? If they’re getting the traffic and attention they need?

They make another mistake…

2. They expect their clients to evaluate them accurately.

Imagine that a prospective client is in the market for a real estate attorney. They’re not sure where to start so they spend some time searching on Google. They create a short list of attorneys to call.

They begin working through their list.

They’re repeatedly forced to sift through jargon, gibberish and noise. Information they either don’t understand or don’t care about.

Like this.

“…dedicated to providing advice and expertise at the highest levels. We have achieved extraordinary results following the distinctive vision of our founders — a cohesive team of lawyers intensely focused on solving our clients’ most important problems.”

Or this.

“Each of our practice areas is highly regarded, and our lawyers are recognized around the world for their commitment to the representation of our clients’ interests.”

Which is basically a long-winded way of saying “we’re good at our jobs. Please hire us.” It doesn’t give clients anything clear they can use to evaluate these firms. Which is a problem because clients are looking for a way to quickly sort through their list. They’re short on expertise so they tend to focus  their attention on two specific areas.

Credibility and outcomes.

Your clients use local search to quickly sort through candidates. Credibility and outcome markers help them qualify or disqualify potential candidates.  

Your clients look for details like…

  •       Precise dollar amounts (which you can’t share) and the number of settlements you’ve won
  •       Your experience with cases like theirs
  •       Your win/lose ratio
  •       Specifics on your story and character
  •       Awards, recognition and testimonials
  •       Uniqueness that shows you have an edge over your competitors and in court

See where I’m going with this?

Outcomes are straightforward. Your clients want a specific answer to one question: “What specifically have you done for others like me?

The more compelling your answer, the higher your conversion rate.


Bill4Time 30 Day Free Trial

In local search for lawyers, your conversion rate is the key to success

Want to receive more qualified clients than you can handle?

It starts with your local content.

What exactly is local content and why is it so important? Your local content tells people and search engines what your business, product or service is all about. That’s incredibly important because this gives Google the tools it needs to rank lawyers appropriately.

Local content includes…

  •       Your GMB listings and local packs
  •       Reviews via mainstream sources like Google and Facebook
  •       Reviews via specialty sources like Avvo and Martindale
  •       Local press coverage (e.g. news, press releases, profile pieces, etc.)
  •       Active social media profiles
  •       Contact info
  •       About pages with pictures or video of real people
  •       Events in the community
  •       Blog posts
  •       Podcasts, videos or slides
  •       Guest posts on relevant or appropriate outlets
  •       Local advertising via LinkedIn Ads, Facebook Ads or Google AdWords

Lawyers who are starting out may work on these details themselves, but most established lawyers will probably delegate these responsibilities to someone else.

Local content forms the basis of a strong local search / lead generation campaign. So it’s important that you have a clear idea about the things your team should be working on.


When it comes to marketing there are two forms of content.

  1. Education attracts client attention. It can be in the form of a story, entertainment or editorial. A thought piece or a research report. A checklist or a lead magnet. If it teaches clients something they want or need to know, it immediately attracts their attention. Education is important because it (a.) builds authority in the mind of prospective clients and (b.) it establishes your role as a trustworthy caregiver in the caregiver/recipient relationship.
  2. Information informs clients. It deals with logistical and non-logistical questions. When they’re ready to select a firm their fears crop up. What’s your hourly rate? How long does my unused retainer last? Do you bill by the hour or at a flat rate? Where are you located? When are you open? By appointment only or are walk-ins welcome? Information trains clients, showing them how you do business.

If you want to win a significant amount of new clients you need both.

Seems obvious doesn’t it?

It’s the first step in a successful campaign but it’s also the portion most law firms get wrong. Where specifically do they go wrong?

  1. They create content that’s top heavy – too much information, not enough education.
  2. Share lots of information but fail to educate – ensuring clients haggle over hourly rates or complain about service.
  3. Their local search profile is lopsided (e.g. lawyers share lots of content on Avvo but neglect Google reviews, Martindale, local directories and social media profiles).

Local search is about quality and quantity.

The competitive landscape is incredibly crowded. Law firms with the largest amount of high quality local content – the firms that focus on credibility and outcomes – rise to the top.

What does that look like?

Let’s take a look at the Law Offices of Kirk Obear & Associates to find out.

kirk obear profile image


We’re looking for credibility and outcomes. Does anything about Obear stands out?

Take a look.


Obear Outcomes from website


His about page is loaded with credibility and outcomes.

  •       Practicing law for more than 20 years
  •       Licensed to practice in several states
  •       Was a prosecutor for the Air Force and the federal government
  •       He’s defended clients throughout the country and around the world
  •       He’s connected to a lot of very powerful people
  •       Personally litigated 100 jury trials, some attorneys
  •       His advocacy has resulted in over 1,000 jury acquittals, amendments, or dismissals
  •       He teaches other lawyers how to do their jobs
  •       He has his own radio show
  •       He leads other criminal defense lawyers

What about his local search profile?


Obear's local Google My Business listing


Obear search engine results


What about local content? He was featured on SuperLawyers.


Obear's Superlawyers profile page


He’s a contributor to the Wisconsin Law Journal.


Obear's listing in the Wisconsin Law Journal


Can you see what’s happening?

Using a variety of local search content, Obear gives prospective clients the credibility and outcome markers they need. His resume is impressive, it establishes him as an authority and is far more likely to cement him as a leading candidate with prospective clients.

What about you?

Want to win more clients with local search? You’ll need to…

Lead with content.

It sounds overwhelming but it doesn’t have to be. It’s as simple as claiming what’s yours. Here are some simple steps you can follow.

  1. Claim or create your listings on Google My Business, Apple Maps and Bing.
  2. Use aggregators to claim and verify your business. Aggregators like Yext create listings in dozens of key directories and social networks like Foursquare, YP, CitySearch and more.
  3. Complete your profile. Add hours of operation, contact details, phone numbers, your website address – anything customers need to work with your business.
  4. Be a consistent creator. Create local content, reach out to local, high traffic publications. Pitch content to them. Use an irresistible offer to lure readers back to your site. Publish a podcast. Approach talk radio shows as a guest. Pitch a Q&A column to up-and-coming sites.

Did you catch the secret to local search?

It’s giving.

Make it a habit to give potential clients your best. Give them high quality education and clear information consistently. Use the platform provided by well known brands to win new clients quickly. Give your agency or your team, the data they need to answer your client’s subconscious question.

What kind of lawyer are you?

Your clients want to know.

Your clients know they don’t know the law. They can’t tell you and your competitors apart. They’re vulnerable, they’re lost and they know it.

Your clients search for credibility and outcomes.

Exceptional content in the form of education and information. Give prospective clients the data they need and they’ll reward you with more attention and more business than you can handle. Your client needs are exceptionally simple.

Protect me, make my problems go away.

Don’t tell clients you can do this for them. Show them clearly. They’re simple, naive and occasionally unrealistic. What’s worse, they know it. They need your help.

Local search isn’t for lawyers.

It’s for your clients, the people, corporations and interests you serve. Use local search well and clients will see they’re lost without you.


Bill4Time 30 Day Free Trial

Written by Andrew McDermott

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.